.png)
The day has finally come. Taylor finally owns Speak Now. This was the first album of hers I went and bought at Target on release day in 2010, decked out in my crimped hair and Fearless Tour t-shirt. While we've seen so many evolutions of Taylor over the years, I feel like 100% self-written Speak Now and now Speak Now (Taylor's Version) are the collection of songs that are the absolute most "Taylor" at her core. While some things have changed from the original Speak Now, ultimately Speak Now (Taylor's Version) takes an album that was exceptional 13 years ago and recreates it with intensified instrumental production and matured vocals-- and then tacks on possibly the best string of From the Vault tracks to date.
Stand-out tracks: "Dear John (Taylor's Version)" "Better Than Revenge (Taylor's Version)" "I Can See You (Taylor's Version) (From the Vault)"
My favorites: "Sparks Fly (Taylor's Version) "Back to December (Taylor's Version)" "Haunted (Taylor's Version)" "Long Live (Taylor's Version)" "Castles Crumbling (feat. Hayley Williams) (Taylor's Version) (From the Vault)"
The album starts with that same charming "oh oh" of "Mine (Taylor's Version)." Between the incredibly detailed storytelling, particularly the bridge ("and I remember that fight, two-thirty a.m./when everything was slipping right out of our hands/I ran out, crying, and you followed me out into the street/braced myself for the goodbye/cause that's all I've ever known/then you took me by surprise/you said, 'I'll never leave you alone'"), and power vocals that really convey the passion of the outro ("you are the best thing that's ever been mine/yes, yes, do you believe it?/we're gonna make it now") this is one of those instant-classic Taylor Swift love songs done exactly right. My favorite song from the original Speak Now (and one of my top 5 favorite Taylor songs ever) is "Sparks Fly"-- maybe it's how intensely ingrained the original is in my ears and heart, but the emotionality that oozes out of the original isn't quite there in the re-recorded version. I fully acknowledge that I'm being nit-picky, so I'll also easily admit that "Sparks Fly (Taylor's Version)" remains one of my favorites based on the song itself-- this just might be one that I turn to my physical copies of the 2010 version of the album more often. "Back to December (Taylor's Version)" is the perfect example of a song that was perfect when it was released in 2010 and recreating it with fuller violins and guitars makes it all the more heartbreakingly romantic. I will never forget the absolute magic that was seeing this one performed on piano and mashed up with OneRepublic's "Apologize" on the Speak Now Tour in 2011-- "Back to December (Taylor's Version)" simply just got better with age.
One of the most powerful moments of the entire album is the bridge of "Dear John (Taylor's Version), when Taylor belts out "I'm shining like fireworks over your sad empty town." After the absolutely heartwrenching tale strung out in this song of a girl who was "too young to be messed with/the girl in the dress, cried the whole way home" and knowing all that girl came to become, that line really hits home, especially in the re-recorded version. "The Story of Us (Taylor's Version)" is lyrically genius in its storybook references and its instrumentation that is chaotic in the best way. The re-recorded version of this one is infinitely better than the original thanks to the noticeable power Taylor's voice has developed over the last 13 years and the punch of modern production on those drums that had Taylor shouting "Can I please see you jump?!" back on the Speak Now Tour.
A theme across the entirety of Speak Now (Taylor's Version) is the absolute precision in lyrical metaphors and the illustrative details of the storytelling of genuinely every single song. Of the re-recorded songs from the original album, "Never Grow Up (Taylor's Version)," "Enchanted (Taylor's Version," and "Innocent (Taylor's Version)" are among the most strikingly visual in their lyrical and instrumental composition. "Never Grow Up (Taylor's Version)" is pared back and simple, allowing the lullaby-like melodies and stories of the nostalgia of growing pains to take center stage, while "Enchanted (Taylor's Version)" and "Innocent (Taylor's Version)" are grander and certainly more wistful-- while Speak Now (Taylor's Version) is full of dazzling bridges, these two might have the best of the bunch (hello the growing violins behind "Please don't be in love with someone else/please don't have somebody waiting on you" and ground-shaking drums backing lyrics like "Time turns flames to embers/you'll have new Septembers/every one of us has messed up too/minds change like the weather/I hope you remember/today is never too late to be brand new").
The first lyric change of Taylor's re-recording process comes in "Better Than Revenge (Taylor's Version)," which automatically draws your attention to the lyrics-- however for me, the biggest star of this song is the absolutely delicious electric guitars and the wicked spoken backing vocals, with"think about what you did" being particularly scathing. Despite the lyric change, "Better Than Revenge (Taylor's Version)" remains searing towards the girl who stole her man and I continue to be astounded by the sheer volume of words Taylor managed to squeeze into this song. Remember what I said earlier about "Sparks Fly (Taylor's Version) losing some of the emotionality from the 2010 version? "Better Than Revenge (Taylor's Version) hasn't lost an ounce of the scorching emotion from the original. My other favorite track from the original Speak Now is "Haunted" and "Haunted (Taylor's Version)" takes the incredibly impressive pairing of violin and electric guitar coupled with quite simply haunting lyricism and makes a song that was great on the original album even better. My favorite detail of "Haunted (Taylor's Version)"? The emphasized bells in the intro that immediately take me back to the ringing gold bells on stage at the Speak Now Tour while a red-dress-clad Taylor struck them dramatically with a mallet during this song. It's the little details.
The end of the original standard album comes with "Long Live (Taylor's Version)". There really aren't words that can accurately describe the way this song makes me feel 13 years, 7 albums, and countless Taylor-related memories later. In the re-recorded album prologue Taylor writes that "Long Live (Taylor's Version)" is for "those people, the ones who thought I had been good enough all along"-- every little bit of the gratitude she feels for us really does shine through on one of the most heartfelt and genuinely grateful songs she's ever written, especially in the re-recorded version.
Let's dive into the From the Vault tracks. After listening to all of them a couple of times, I'm incredibly impressed by the instrumental range of these songs as well as the fact that they're brand new in 2023, but sound exactly like they were released in 2010 along with the original album. "Electric Touch (feat. Fall Out Boy) (Taylor's Version) (From the Vault)" is continued proof that a pop-rock Taylor album would be unstoppable-- from supple drums and encompassing vocals on the choruses chanting lyrics like "all I know is this could either break my heart/or bring it back to life" to the little bit of flair added by the Fall Out Boy feature, this song is a 2010 pop-rock dream. "When Emma Falls in Love (Taylor's Version) (From the Vault)" is honestly probably my least favorite of the From the Vault tracks, which puts into perspective how good all of them are. Starting with a simple piano-and-vocal that sounds poetic, the song then blossoms into the classic Speak Now-era instrumentals of drums, banjo, guitars, and dreamy backing vocals and idyllic lyrics like "she's the kinda book that you can't put down/like if Cleopatra grew up in a small town/and all the bad boys would be good boys/if they only had the chance to love her."
The next two From the Vault tracks are my personal favorites. "I Can See You (Taylor's Version) (From the Vault)" is going to be the "All Too Well (10-Minute Version)" of this album with its catchy electric-guitar led instrumentals and the incredibly sleek and sexy lyrics that are shocking to have been written by 18-year old Taylor. [Edit: The music video for this song has been released since I wrote this review and HELLO? Taylor Lautner and Joey King breaking into the Speak Now vault to save Speak Now Tour Taylor??? To represent how fans have helped her take back her art??? I'll be talking about this one for A LONG TIME.] "Castles Crumbling (feat. Hayley Williams) (Taylor's Version) (From the Vault)" is the heartbreaking anti-"Long Live"-- every emotion of being built up so high that it gets to be lonely and scary is laid out with the perfect balance of power and vulnerability. The lyrics are truly the star of the show on this song; examples include "used to chant my name/now they're screaming that they hate me/never wanted you to hate me" and "power went to my head and I couldn't stop/ones I loved tried to help, so I ran them off/and here I sit alone behind walls of regret/falling down like promises that I never kept."
"Foolish One (Taylor's Version) (From the Vault)" is probably the From the Vault track that genuinely sounds the most like it came straight off the original 2010 Speak Now album. Guitar-piano-drum instrumentals, "la la la's," and poignantly overdramatic-yet-romantic lyrics like "now I'm slidin' down the wall with my head in my hands/sayin', 'How could I not see the signs?'/you haven't written me or called" make this track absolutely classic Speak Now. The album concludes after 22 tracks with "Timeless (Taylor's Version) (From the Vault)." This one is "Mine" meets Taylor Swift's "Mary's Song (Oh My My My)"-- it's a love letter to love stories that span years against all odds. "That's when I came upon a book covered in cobwebs/story of a romance torn apart by fate/hundreds of years ago, they fell in love like we did/and I'd die for you in the same way if I first saw your face" is just exactly the right tone to end the album on with its captivating yet simple nostalgia and romance.
In my opinion, Speak Now (Taylor's Version) is one of Taylor's greatest triumphs as a musician thus far. The original album was a skip-less classic-- now with updated instrumentals and matured vocals and sonically cohesive powerhouses of From the Vault tracks, Speak Now (Taylor's Version) is a magical masterpiece.
AM I OBSESSED?
Comments